What Should I Do If the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Contacts Me for a Recorded Statement?

Don’t let the insurance companies use their tactics against you

Dealing with the aftermath of a car accident in Arizona can feel overwhelming, especially when the other driver’s insurance company calls you asking for a recorded statement. You may not know if you’re required to comply or how your words could impact your case.

Insurance companies often hold the cards to the outcome of your claim. That’s why it’s important to know your rights and avoid common mistakes that could jeopardize your claim. An Arizona car accident lawyer at Browne Law Group can guide you through the process and protect your rights every step of the way.

Should I give a recorded statement?

It’s a fair question – should you give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company? The answer is almost always no. Insurance companies often ask for recorded statements under the guise of getting your side of the story, but they’re really gathering evidence to use against you.

A recorded statement can be a double-edged sword. The insurance adjuster may ask misleading or tricky questions designed to downplay the severity of your car accident or your injuries. Something as simple as saying, “I’m feeling better” could be used to argue that your injuries aren’t as serious as you claim.

Additionally, insurance adjusters are trained to twist your words, so it’s best to avoid giving a statement without first getting legal representation.

What tactics do insurance companies use to minimize my claim?

Insurance companies are notorious for using every trick in the book to minimize the amount they have to pay. These aren’t your everyday conversations – they’re strategic moves. Adjusters may come across as friendly and concerned, but their goal is simple: pay you as little as possible.

Common tactics include asking open-ended questions that seem harmless but are designed to make you contradict yourself. They might ask about your medical history and try to pin your injuries on a pre-existing condition. Or they might claim they “just need to clear up a few details” when they’re actually looking for inconsistencies in your story. The bottom line is they’re not your friend.

What questions do insurance adjusters typically ask?

Insurance adjusters often ask trick questions such as:

• Can you describe how the car accident happened?

They want to hear your version of events, but they may try to catch you in inconsistencies.

• What were you doing just before the car accident happened?

This question is meant to find out if you were distracted, possibly shifting some blame to you.

• Did you get medical treatment immediately after the accident?

If you didn’t seek medical help right away, they might argue your injuries aren’t serious.

• Have you had any previous injuries or medical conditions?

They could use pre-existing conditions to claim your injuries weren’t caused by the accident.

• Can you describe the damage to your vehicle?

This helps them assess the severity of the crash, but they may downplay the damage.

What should I say if I’m contacted for a recorded statement?

If you’re involved in a crash and the other driver’s insurance company calls and asks for a recorded statement, your best bet is to decline politely but firmly. You’re not legally required to provide a recorded statement, and agreeing to one can open a can of worms you’d rather leave shut.

Here’s a simple script to follow: “I’m not comfortable giving a recorded statement right now. I need to speak with my attorney first.” This stops the adjuster in their tracks without sounding rude.

Can I refuse to provide a recorded statement in Arizona?

You can absolutely refuse to provide a recorded statement in Arizona. You are under no legal obligation to give the other driver’s insurance company a recorded statement, no matter how insistent they may be.

Refusing to give a statement doesn’t mean you’re being uncooperative. It simply means you’re protecting your interests. You have the right to consult an attorney before agreeing to anything – and in most cases, that’s exactly what you should do.

What are the next steps after declining to give a recorded statement?

After you decline the request for a recorded statement, the next step is to focus on building a solid case. This includes gathering evidence, seeking medical treatment, and contacting a skilled Arizona car accident lawyer. The more documentation you have – from medical records to photos of the accident scene – the stronger your case will be.

You should also follow all legal and medical advice. That means attending all medical appointments, adhering to treatment plans, and refraining from activities that could disprove your claim or worsen your injuries. You should also avoid posting about your car accident on social media.

The other driver’s insurance company may be watching, even without your knowledge. For example, if you’re out playing golf while pursuing a claim, the insurance company will use any visible evidence against you.

When should I accept a settlement from the other driver’s insurance company?

You should consider accepting a settlement from the other driver’s insurance company only when you have a clear understanding of the full extent of your injuries and damages. This includes medical bills, future medical treatment, lost wages, property damage, and any pain and suffering you’ve experienced.

It’s best to wait until you’ve reached maximum medical improvement, which means your doctor has determined that your condition has stabilized and you won’t need further treatment. Accepting a settlement too early can leave you with out-of-pocket expenses for future medical care that won’t be covered.

Once you accept a settlement offer, it will be very difficult to seek additional compensation if new damages arise. It’s important to be patient, as the process can take some time. Let an experienced Arizona car accident attorney determine the true value of your claim before accepting a settlement.

Let our Arizona law firm fight for your rights

If you or a loved one was injured in a car accident in Arizona, you need a strong legal advocate on your side who does more than just handle paperwork. Browne Law Group can help you level the playing field against the insurance companies and get the maximum compensation you’re entitled to.

Our law firm takes a no-nonsense approach to handling car accident cases like yours. With years of experience helping injured victims in Gilbert and across Maricopa County, we fight aggressively for our clients. We have the case results to prove it, including $2.75 million for a client injured in a crash with a drunk driver.

We can handle every aspect of your claim from gathering initial evidence to negotiating for a maximum settlement. Plus, we have a no-fee policy, which means you owe nothing unless we win your case. Contact us online or call us today for a free consultation and let us fight for the compensation you deserve.

Click here to download a printable PDF of this article, “What Should I Do If the Other Driver’s Insurance Company Contacts Me for a Recorded Statement?”